Skip to main content

In Defiance of Founders’ Plan, Trump Bans Media from the White House to Escape Scrutiny and Accountability

President Donald Trump’s decision to ban CNN, MS Now and Politico from the White House, a function of his groundless claims that the outlets engage in “fake news,” a euphemism for his irrational rage against the media for news coverage that he dislikes, has morphed into an after-the-fact litigation posture that invokes squishy “national security” concerns as justification for the iron curtain that he would impose to avoid oversight, scrutiny and accountability.  

    Trump’s latest ban on journalists and news organizations that refuse to do his bidding, violates a history of case law that stands for the principle that denying or restricting journalists’ access to the White House based on their reporting violates the First Amendment’s Freedom of the Press Clause. More than an exercise in “viewpoint discrimination,” failure of the White House to provide a clearly stated justification for any denial violates the Fifth Amendment’s due process clause. 

   Beyond Trump’s trampling of the Constitution, indeed, of foundational rights, is his offense against the cherished, centuries-old rationale for freedom of the press. The English commentator, William Blackstone, rightly observed that, “The liberty of the press is indeed essential to the nature of a free state.”  The founders of our republic, who looked to Blackstone at every turn for their education about the English constitution and common law, saw clearly that freedom of the press was indispensable to the existence of a free and responsible government.  

     President Trump has never made a secret of his contempt for freedom of the press.  Readers will recall his earliest rants against reporters, uttered frequently on the campaign trail in his first run for the presidency. Reporters, he said, are “scum of the earth.” The press, he delighted in saying, is “the enemy of the people,” seizing the line from them lips of totalitarian leaders in the 20th Century. Trump told his audiences, “Don’t believe what you read or hear. Believe what I tell you.” The Associated Press was banned from the White House for steadfastly referring in its reporting to the “Gulf of Mexico,” rather than Trump’s petulant preference for “Gulf of America.” With that lesson, we should surmise that news organizations that will adhere to the name, “Lake Ontario,” will be punished if they don’t adopt Trump’s preference for “Lake America.” 

    James Madison, who described freedom of the press as one of the “choicest” of the “great rights of mankind,” understood as well as any of the nation’s founders that a free press was critical to the functioning of popular government and the protection of civil liberties. His fellow Virginian, Thomas Jefferson, nailed its importance when he referred to freedom of the press as the “people’s right to know.” Without a free press to report on the activities of government—at any level—the people will depend for their knowledge about official activities on those most interested in shaping the understanding and opinions of the electorate. A citizenry solely dependent on the representations of those anxious to win public support—and votes—will be vulnerable to manipulation and deceit by elected officials who, in a system of government based on popular participation, most require the scrutiny and oversight that only a free and independent press can provide. Banning reporters is an efficient way for governmental leaders to hide their deceit. 

   The Supreme Court, in its most famous free press case, The New York Times v. United States (1971), was alert to presidential efforts to withhold and hide information behind the thinly veiled assertion of “national security.” Of the several opinions written by the Justices, the most powerful, long-lasting and eloquent of the lot, was Justice Hugo Black’s. Black’s opinion, his last, before illness and death in September, was one of his most memorable.  “The press was protected,” he wrote, “so that it could bare the secrets of government and inform the people. Only a free and unrestrained press can effectively expose deception in government.”  Black wrote that the press in exposing the government’s deception about the Vietnam War, should be “commended” for serving the framers’ purpose. “In revealing the workings of the government that led to the Vietnam War, the newspapers nobly did precisely that which the Founders hoped and trusted they would do.” 

   Banning news organizations from the White House for coverage that the president dislikes defies the framers’ purpose in crafting the free press clause.