Catch Me if You Can: “Trump’s Lawless Presidency”
Donald Trump’s conception of executive power, aptly characterized by Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson as a “Catch-Me-If-You-Can” presidency, previously described in this space as one grounded in the Machiavellian philosophy— “the ends justify the means”—violates every precept of the rule of law. For Trump, statutes, rules, norms and constitutional provisions don’t exist. As restraints, they may as well be invisible. He does what he wants and truly believes, as he said, repeatedly, that he enjoys “absolute power under Article II.” As he has told advisers and audiences, “I’m the President I can do whatever I want to do.”
Trump’s approach resembles what some readers will find familiar in the activities of their daily lives: “better to ask for forgiveness than permission.” The difference is that Trump seeks neither permission nor forgiveness for trampling the Constitution and the framers stated aim of subordinating the presidency to the rule of law and rendering it amenable to the judicial process. He has demonstrated, repeatedly, a propensity to outrun the law and the reach of the courts. This is not what the framers had in mind when they wrote in Article II that “the president shall faithfully execute the law.” It is not what the Oath of Office contemplates. It certainly is not what George Washington had in mind in warning presidents to avoid even the appearance of usurpation of power.
That was then, this is now. The most recent example of Trump’s contempt for the law is reflected in his to build a huge ballroom, even though he is doing it in direct violation of the law, which requires congressional authorization. The Trump Administration makes no secret of its policy of “outrunning” the law. Solicitor General John Sauer has written that Trump “has raced to ‘outrun” the extraordinary security threats facing this president.” Nobody outside Trump’s sycophantic circle has suggested that his erection of a ballroom meets national security needs.
The fact is, Trump has exploited the slow-moving pace of the deliberative legal process, fully recognizing that the courts cannot move fast enough to deny his every wish, even if his wishes violate the law. There is nothing in this approach that remotely satisfies the Article II “duty” to “faithfully” execute the laws. Thus, Justice Jackson’s apt characterization of the Trump Presidency.
The framers of the Constitution, men of considerable experience and, as body, a good judge of character, and in possession of the prescience to anticipate an ambitious executive who would flaunt the Constitution and the nation’s laws, supplied a remedy: impeachment. Benjamin Franklin, the oldest delegate in the Philadelphia Convention, and perhaps its wisest member, observed that without the authority to impeach the president, there would be no recourse, but “to assassination.”
Alas, the impeachment power is granted to Congress which, these days, is controlled by a Republican majority, filled with Trump supplicants who would rather abide Trump’s assault on the Constitution, the rule of law, separation of powers, checks and balances and the Bill of Rights, rather than risk his wrath for daring to criticize him. The framers believed that they had created a constitutional system capable of constraining a “Catch-Me-If-You-Can” presidency, but the constraints require good men and women at the helm, those in possession of integrity and dignity, and ready to implement the legal machinery necessary to defend the republic, rather than facilitating its demise.
We are entitled to wonder at this juncture, whether the Madisonian Constitution has met its match in the authoritarian presidency of Donald Trump. Not since the Civil War, when the preservation of the republic was a real question, have Americans faced this existential threat. At that moment, when the North and South faced off, the country was fortunate to be led by Lincoln. Where is our Lincoln today?